BRUNELLO CUCINELLILAWSUIT ARCHIVE
Home / Archive / Antitrust & Competition
APPEAL DECIDED — DISMISSAL AFFIRMED

Giordano, Hayes & Wang et al. v. Saks Incorporated et al.

A proposed class action challenging alleged no-hire arrangements between Saks and luxury concessionaires.

Legal-status note: A complaint contains allegations, not established facts. Dismissal, settlement, administrative action and judicial findings are labeled separately throughout this archive.

Overview

A proposed class action challenging alleged no-hire arrangements between Saks and luxury concessionaires.

Allegations / Issues Presented

Plaintiffs alleged an agreement that unlawfully restricted employee mobility and suppressed compensation. The allegations were contested. The U.S. Department of Justice participated as amicus on appeal.

Procedural History & Current Status

The district court dismissed the claims. The Second Circuit affirmed the dismissal on March 13, 2025. The appellate analysis addressed, among other issues, the alleged vertical/horizontal nature of the restrictions and timeliness.

Company Position / Context

The dismissal and affirmance mean the plaintiffs did not obtain a merits judgment imposing liability on Brunello Cucinelli USA in this action.

Primary & Public Sources

Use the source links at right to review the underlying public record where available. Some federal or state docket documents may require PACER, a court portal, or a third-party docket service.